Your rights after a non-fault accident
If another driver caused your accident, the law aims to put you back in the position you were in before it happened. In practice that gives you more choice and more protection than most insurers will tell you about. Here are the six rights that matter most, and what to do if someone tries to ignore them.
Right 1: You choose who repairs your vehicle
When your losses are being recovered from the at-fault driver, you are entitled to have your vehicle repaired properly by a repairer you trust. The at-fault driver's insurer may call you offering to arrange everything through its own network. You don't have to accept. Its priority is controlling its own costs, not yours.
If you claim on your own policy instead, your insurer's terms may limit your choice of garage. That is one reason many non-fault drivers prefer to claim directly against the at-fault party.
Right 2: A comparable replacement vehicle
If you need a vehicle while yours is off the road, you can claim the reasonable cost of a replacement that is comparable to your own. A small hatchback courtesy car is not a like-for-like replacement for a seven-seat family car, a van you use for work or a prestige saloon.
You do need to show you genuinely need a vehicle, and the hire should only last as long as is reasonable. See our guide on courtesy cars vs replacement cars.
Right 3: A proper, safe repair
A reasonable repair follows the manufacturer's repair methods, uses parts of matching quality and includes any calibration the vehicle needs afterwards. Modern cars rely on cameras and radar for features such as automatic emergency braking and lane-keeping, so ADAS recalibration is part of putting the car right, not an optional extra.
Right 4: Not to be out of pocket for your excess
If your claim is made directly against the at-fault driver's insurer, there is no excess to pay, because your own policy isn't being used. If you have already claimed on your own policy, your excess is an uninsured loss you can recover from the at-fault party. Read more in do I pay my excess if it wasn't my fault?
Right 5: To recover your other losses
Your vehicle is only part of the picture. Depending on your circumstances you may also be able to recover:
- recovery and storage charges
- reasonable travel costs, such as taxis or train fares, if you go without a vehicle
- loss of earnings if you use your vehicle for work, for example as a taxi driver
- items damaged in the vehicle, such as a child seat or dashcam
- loss in value where a repaired vehicle is worth less because of its accident history
Keep receipts and records for everything. Losses you can evidence are far easier to recover.
Right 6: A fair valuation if your vehicle is written off
If your vehicle is beyond economic repair, you are entitled to its pre-accident market value, not the lowest figure an insurer can justify. You can challenge a valuation with evidence of what similar vehicles are actually selling for. See car written off and it wasn't your fault.
What to do if your rights are being ignored
- Put it in writing. Phone calls are easily forgotten. Email the insurer, set out what you want and why, and keep copies.
- Make a formal complaint if you are dealing with your own insurer. It must follow a complaints process.
- Take it to the Financial Ombudsman Service if your own insurer doesn't resolve your complaint within eight weeks or you disagree with its final response.
- Get help. Talk to us, Citizens Advice or a solicitor before accepting an offer you are unhappy with.
How long do you have to make a claim?
In England and Wales, claims for damage to property such as your vehicle generally must be started within six years of the accident (three years if someone was injured). Don't wait: evidence fades, storage charges build up and insurers move faster when you act quickly.
Frequently asked questions
Do I have to deal with the at-fault driver's insurer myself?
No. You can ask someone to manage the process on your behalf. We arrange your recovery, repair and replacement vehicle and deal with the at-fault insurer for you.
What if the other driver disputes who was at fault?
Your claim may take longer while liability is investigated. Evidence such as photos, dashcam footage and witness details makes a real difference, so gather as much as you can at the scene.
Can I claim if the other driver had no insurance?
Usually, yes, through the Motor Insurers' Bureau. See our guide to being hit by an uninsured or hit-and-run driver.
Do you handle injury claims?
No. We deal with vehicle damage and related losses only. If you were injured, speak to a solicitor who specialises in personal injury.
Not your fault? Let's get you back on the road.
Tell us what happened and we'll call you back, usually the same working day.
Rated by real customers on Trustpilot
Your vehicle is repaired at BS 10125 certified repair centres in Slough and Uxbridge. Don't take our word for it: read what their customers say.
Slough repair centre
Serving East Berkshire, Reading, South Buckinghamshire and North Surrey.
Uxbridge repair centre
Serving West London, Heathrow and South Buckinghamshire.